What’s in a News Wiki?

News wikis haven’t make it big yet but, in my opinion, their day is soon.

In a conversation I was having with Joey Baker the other day, we were talking about micropayments, monetization, and how news differs from music, movies, and other forums of content. His argument is that news is “read once, and then file away” while the other forms have “repeat use” value which makes them easier to charge for. This got me thinking. Journalism shouldn’t just be about broadcasting the most recent event of the day, but also providing accurate, vetted, and independent information to educate the community. In fact, news websites are pretty bad with this other side of journalism. If I want to understand the context for an issue’s current situation beyond what’s presented in the article, I’ve got to use an atrocious site search tool to find previous articles on the issue. There has to be a better way to get me to the information I need to know.

Enter: the wiki.

More specifically, a topical wiki that would emphasize finding information by subject as opposed to date. I’m building off of two examples that do part of what I’m thinking about: NY Times Topics and the Guardian website. What I like about the Times Topics website are the *pedia-esque articles that synthesize the latest information into a two to three minute summary. It’s a good starting point, much like Wikipedia, for learning more about a subject. The Guardian website strikes my fancy because of the ability to choose what I’m interested in by subject, and then be able to drill down deeper a la Delicious:

Guardian website - topical navigation

I think these ideas should be merged with a few more in the mix. The context for the design of this news wiki is student government on a university campus, specifically the Associated Students of the University of Oregon (ASUO). This is what I would call a real-life example.

At the moment, if I as a student want to have any idea of what’s going on in student government, what bills are being voted on, and where my money is being used, I’d have to do some sleuthing. The most recent articles about the ASUO in the Daily Emerald will get me started, but I’d have to search across multiple sites, sift through a lot of information, and draft my own conclusions.

Instead, a landing page for the ASUO (and, a la the Guardian website, with nested topics) that was provided, developed, and maintained by a student news organization would be the first place I would go to get myself better acquainted with where the student government was currently at. Here is how it would present information:

  • A *pedia article moderated by the beat reporter that anyone in the community could contribute to. To keep the conversation civil, all edits would have to be verifiable. This article would be a four to six paragraph synthesis of what the ASUO was about, what the history was, and what the current issues were.
  • Content (including articles, images, and video) within the news organization by most recent, most commented, and most favorited. You’d be able to visualize all of these across a timeline too, in order to get a better understanding of what conversation was happening when.
  • By bringing in the conversation from the community. If bloggers used “ASUO” as one of the tags for posts about the student government, that content too would be automatically pulled in and linked to. The same thing would apply for tweets, images on Flickr, and video conversation on Seesmic.

The cool thing is that you could have topics nested within your taxonomy, too. For instance, as a student wanting to educate myself about the student government, I’d start with the primary topic page. If there was an issue that caught my eye, I could click through to get a more refined *pedia article, list of posts on that specific subject, and maybe even the ASUO documents related to their discussion. 

I present the student news wiki, a living topical archive to inform the community.

7 comments

  1. This is one of the most winning ideas I’ve heard from you, Daniel.

    I think the contextualization that you’re suggesting (by using a wiki) is wonderful. Reminds me a bit of the Semantic Web concept that has been generating buzz the last year or two (maybe longer?).

    I think keeping the articles to a limited size is important.

    Couple risks I see: 1) Trying to have all the content in the world under one roof. 2) Getting users to actually explore the ASUO wiki link. They would need a way to know that it’s a short summary instead of a link to their home page.

    Couple other comments:
    Although it doesn’t directly relate to the idea your proposing, I think wiki news deserves a mention.

    It’s funny you should mention the confusing ASUO system. Every time I am involved with something, I constantly take mental notes about how the processes could be improved for the future. In terms of my recent work with the ASUO, I’ve considered making a wiki specifically about the ASUO and their processes. It would be nearly impossible to get anyone besides myself to contribute content, but it would be insanely useful (if anyone were able to find it, which would be difficult also). I think the focus of the wiki would be to provide “use cases” for your interaction with the ASUO. Then you can see step-by-step directions. It would be a roadmap for interactions.

    Maybe I should get the senate to create a new position: Web Czar. I could make their website usable and effective. Haha.

  2. Andrew says:

    Nice post, some really great ideas in there. I also like the idea of keeping the articles short.

    I think that the biggest obstacle here would be the use of it. In past experience the hardest part about getting wikis (and even group blogs) off of the ground is getting students to actually use them. Our generation just seems to be too comfortable in consuming info without producing any.

  3. @Jeremy, I think you raise a good point about “getting users to actually explore the ASUO wiki link.” A bit of CSS (to distinguish between internal and external links) and reader education would easily fix this. You could also allow the option of reporting to the FB News Feed every time you made a significant contribution to the wiki. With the right design, I don’t actually think this would be too big of a problem.

  4. [...] TechCrunch, then I would visit it every day. Innovate with the formats of journalism too; start a topical wiki that aggregates and synthesizes information on any given subject.  If you create an account on the site, or sign in via OpenID, allows users [...]

  5. [...] and context your reporters are finding. A wiki dedicated specifically to this topic, much like the topical wiki I’ve described before, could provide the background information necessary to bring people up to speed, including how many [...]

  6. [...] wasn’t satisfied with how the New York Times presented information to me. If they launched a true news wiki with similar or superior accessibility, I think they could steal my attention back for one reason: the New York Time has a brand of [...]

  7. [...] Currently there’s no functionality for users to participate in the production of the page, a key component of the news wiki idea I’ve written about before, but what they have is a very cool start. Paul Bradshaw has more. (tks Brian [...]

Leave a comment